Home
Back to Botanical extracts

Botanical extracts

Organic Extracts: Two Certificates, Not One

The farm's certificate ends at the gate. How the 95% threshold breaks on a carrier, which five documents answer the question, and where the chain is usually lost.

A PDF arrives with a farm's name on it, a hectare count, and a scope that covers the growing and drying of astragalus. The buyer forwards it to the brand and the brand asks the obvious question: where is the certificate for the extract?

The silence that follows is not rudeness. It is the shape of the system. Organic certification attaches to an operation, not to a plant, and the farm's operation ends at the farm gate.

The certificate stops at the gate

In the United States, a handler that processes organic agricultural products needs its own certification under the National Organic Program, with its own organic system plan, its own inspection, and its own certificate. In the European Union, the operator is certified under Regulation (EU) 2018/848 by a control body, and the certificate names the categories of product the operator is certified for.

An extractor is a handler. It buys dried root, extracts it, adds a carrier, dries it, and puts it in a drum. Every one of those steps is a point where a non-organic input can enter, which is why the certifier wants to inspect the building rather than the field.

So a material can be made from herb that was 100% certified organic and still be a non-organic product. The gap sits at the operation that turned the herb into a powder, which has no certificate of its own.

The 95% is a weight fraction of the formula

Both systems write the claim as a percentage of the finished product, and that is where most misunderstandings start.

In the United States, a product labelled organic must contain at least 95% organically produced ingredients by weight, excluding water and salt. The remaining 5% must be either a non-agricultural substance on the National List or a non-organic agricultural ingredient that appears on the list of items not commercially available in organic form. A product at 70% or more can say "made with organic" and name the ingredients. Below 70%, the word organic can appear only in the ingredient list, attached to the specific ingredients that are organic.

In the European Union, a product may use the term organic in its name only if at least 95% by weight of its agricultural ingredients are organic, and the EU logo is mandatory on pre-packaged organic food produced in the Union. Below that threshold, organic ingredients can be indicated in the ingredient list, and nothing else.

The arithmetic is over the formula, weighted by mass, so it describes the powder rather than the farm.

Where an extract breaks the arithmetic

Extract powders are the hardest products to fit into a 95% rule, because the largest single ingredient after the extract itself is often the carrier.

A spray-dried powder at 60 parts extract solids and 40 parts maltodextrin, made from 100% organic herb with a conventional carrier, is a product at 60% organic. It cannot be called organic, and it cannot even be called "made with organic". The herb did nothing wrong; the carrier was simply the bigger number in the second half of the formula.

That leaves two practical routes. Use an organic carrier, which is usually organic tapioca or organic rice maltodextrin, or use no carrier at all, which means a liquid extract or a powder that can be dried without a drying aid. Both cost more, and the second one is a process decision that has to be made before the dryer is booked.

The solvent is the other half. Hexane and acetone are not on the National List and are not authorised as extraction solvents for organic production in the Union, so an organic claim and a hexane extraction cannot coexist in the same certificate. Water and ethanol are the practical route, and a certificate's scope usually names the extraction method for that reason.

A heap of pale green powder spilling from a wooden scoop onto a white surface, with a standing kraft paper bag behind it and fresh round leaves at the left
A heap of pale green powder spilling from a wooden scoop onto a white surface, with a standing kraft paper bag behind it and fresh round leaves at the left

What the handler controls

Three things are inspected, and none of them are the herb.

Segregation comes first. A dedicated line is the simplest answer; a shared line is allowed if cleaning is validated and the changeover is recorded. Storage is separated, and the organic material is labelled at every stage.

Fresh round green leaves beside a glass bowl of pale green powder and a steel scoop on a white surface
Fresh round green leaves beside a glass bowl of pale green powder and a steel scoop on a white surface

Mass balance comes second, and it is the document that auditors read before any residue test. One thousand kilograms of organic herb in, some kilograms of extract out, plus the carrier booked as an organic input. The yield has to explain the difference. A mass balance that only reconciles at the end of the year, and not per lot, is the most common finding in an organic audit.

The label comes third. The certifier approves it before print, because the claim, the percentage and the logo are all regulated statements. In the Union, the logo carries the code number of the control body, and a label printed without it cannot be corrected with a sticker at the port.

Residues follow the seal

Organic certification is not a promise that a material is free of pesticide. It is a promise about the inputs and the process, verified by testing a sample.

The tests matter because drift, shared equipment and contaminated storage are ordinary events. A field next door, a lorry that also carried treated grain, a mill used for conventional material on the previous shift: all of them can put a residue into an organic lot without anyone deciding to.

When a result comes back positive, the event is bigger than a certificate of analysis line. It triggers an investigation of the lot, a decision on whether the material can still be sold as organic, and in some cases a notification to the certifier. That is why the 5% allowance is not a licence: the non-organic fraction must be on the list, and it must not be a prohibited substance.

The import file is a third document

Neither system lets a certificate travel with a sample and cover a container. The certificate describes the operation; the consignment needs its own paperwork.

In the European Union, an organic consignment from a third country enters with a certificate of inspection issued through TRACES by a control body recognised for that country, and the weights on it have to match the invoice and the packing list. A discrepancy in kilograms is a stop at the border rather than a note in a file.

In the United States, the importer holds its own certification, and it verifies the supplier through a transaction certificate for the specific lot. The importer is the party that carries the risk, which is why an experienced importer asks for the certificate before the purchase order rather than after the shipment.

There is also a structural problem in this trade that neither system was designed around. The party named on the shipping documents is often a trading company, not the extractor. A certificate in the trader's name answers a question about the trader. What the buyer needs is the name and address of the building where the extraction happened, because that is the operation the inspection covered.

What to ask for

Five documents answer the question that the farm certificate did not.

  • The handler certificate. With the extractor's name and address on it, not the trader's, and with a scope that names the product categories actually handled.
  • The carrier's certificate. Separate, with its own organic share, because the carrier is the ingredient that decides the arithmetic.
  • The mass balance. Per lot, showing herb in, extract out, carrier added, and the yield that explains the difference.
  • The solvent and the process. Named, because the solvent is part of the claim and not only part of the costs.
  • The approved label. As the certifier signed it, with the logo and the control body code, before it is printed rather than after.
A sealed stand-up pouch printed ASTRAGALUS EXTRACT beside a wooden bowl of astragalus slices and a scoop of cream powder on a bench
A sealed stand-up pouch printed ASTRAGALUS EXTRACT beside a wooden bowl of astragalus slices and a scoop of cream powder on a bench

The botanical extract production lines page shows where the carrier enters the process, the carriers and solvents article covers what a carrier does to an assay and to a formula, and the contact page reaches the people who handle the certification files.

Ding Shaohua, Foreign Trade Manager, takes enquiries for this line. The same person answers on WhatsApp, TikTok, LinkedIn and Facebook.

FAQ

If the herb is certified organic, is the extract organic?

Not automatically. Certification belongs to an operation, so the extractor needs its own handler certificate, and the finished powder has to meet the 95% weight threshold on its own formula. A conventional carrier can take a product made from fully organic herb below the threshold, and a solvent that is not permitted can take it out of the category entirely.

Can a conventional carrier be used at all?

Only inside the 5% allowance, and only if it is a substance the National List permits there. A non-organic agricultural ingredient can be counted in that 5% only when it appears on the list of items not commercially available in organic form. Maltodextrin is not an ingredient a buyer should rely on for that route, so in practice an organic extract uses an organic carrier, or none.

Does the 95% mean 95% of the herb was organic?

No. It is 95% of the finished product by weight, water and salt excluded, which is a statement about the formula rather than about the field. A product can be 95% organic and contain herb from two sources, as long as the weighted sum clears the threshold and every non-organic input is permitted.

Can the same building run organic and conventional material?

Yes, with separation and records. A dedicated line is the simplest route; a shared line needs validated cleaning, a recorded changeover and storage that keeps the two streams apart. What the certifier is looking for is not a promise but a paper trail that shows which material was where, on which shift.

All News